Let's talk about 'Elle,' Amazon's new series that has left many viewers scratching their heads. This 'Legally Blonde' prequel, while cute and entertaining, seems to have missed the mark when it comes to its connection to the original film.
The Elle Woods Conundrum
If we view Elle Woods as a unique character with a specific backstory, the new series simply doesn't add up. The original film's premise relied on Elle's naivety and her limited world view, which is completely contradicted by the revelation that she spent her teens in Seattle's grunge scene. It's a narrative inconsistency that's hard to overlook.
However, if we approach 'Elle' as a franchise reboot, akin to the James Bond or Superman series, the show makes more sense from a business perspective. It's a loose adaptation of the source material, and while it doesn't expand on the original concept, it does highlight the adaptability of the 'Legally Blonde' brand.
A Modern-Day Cinderella Story?
The series introduces us to a younger Elle, portrayed by Lexi Minetree, who starts her journey as a privileged high schooler in LA. The choice to set the story in 1995, rather than the early 2000s, gives the show a 'Clueless' vibe, with Elle resembling Cher Horowitz in her sheltered yet confident demeanor.
But then, Elle's world is turned upside down when her family moves to Seattle. Here, her bubbly personality and unique fashion sense become a liability, as she struggles to fit in with the grungy student body. It's an interesting take on the classic fish-out-of-water story, but the show's portrayal of Seattle feels a bit too stereotypical and cheesy.
The Setting's Contradiction
One of the show's biggest issues is the contradiction between its setting and premise. Seattle is portrayed as a haven for punks and rebels, yet everyone seems to be marching to the same beat. This flat portrayal undermines the very idea that Elle is an outsider, as everyone else seems to be conforming to a single, homogeneous style and mindset.
This awkward framing almost feels like a defensive stance, suggesting that rich, straight, feminine white women are the most oppressed group. However, as the show progresses and individual characters become more developed, this effect mellows, allowing the story to focus on Elle's journey and the challenges she faces.
Elle's Journey and the Cast
Much of the show's appeal lies in Lexi Minetree's performance as Elle. She captures the essence of Reese Witherspoon's Elle Woods, nailing every mannerism and vocal inflection. It's a technically impressive and emotionally engaging performance, leaving viewers wishing Minetree had been given more creative freedom to make the role her own.
The supporting cast also shines, with Tom Everett Scott as the dorky dad and June Diane Raphael as Eva, Elle's comic relief mom, who later embarks on her own journey of self-discovery. Among the young cast, Zac Looker as Dustin and Gabrielle Policano as Liz stand out, offering a fresh dynamic to Elle's world.
However, some characters, like Elle's crush Miles, feel like they exist primarily to represent a certain archetype rather than being fully fleshed-out individuals.
Easter Eggs and the Show's Identity Crisis
'Elle' walks a fine line when it comes to Easter eggs from the original film. Some, like the appearance of Bruiser the chihuahua, are delightful nods to the fans. Others, like the suggestion that Elle might become a lawyer one day, feel forced and groan-worthy.
It's clear that the show is trying to capitalize on the affection viewers have for 'Legally Blonde,' but it seems to be struggling to find its own identity. It's caught between being a faithful prequel and a unique, standalone series, leaving viewers with a sense of dissatisfaction.
In conclusion, 'Elle' is an interesting attempt to expand the 'Legally Blonde' universe, but it falls short in its execution. While it has its charming moments and a talented cast, the show's narrative inconsistencies and identity crisis leave a lot to be desired. Personally, I think it's a missed opportunity to explore a fascinating character like Elle Woods in a new and exciting way.
